Rewards
Pulls kind of coral on my skin tone, tho the camera picks up a more vibrant red. Either way it’s gorgeous
The first Cracked polish I tried and my forever love. Such a fun, brilliant color.
True to its name, this jelly is the perfect tomato color! The formula is smooth and builds nicely in one, two, or three coats (as it is a jelly it won't reach full opacity). Love the color and the application.
I was so skeptical about wearing a warm red since my fingers tend towards redness already, but somehow it works?? It shouldn't, but it does. The formula's easy to work with and it looks so juicy on. This is 2 coats + topcoat.
This color skews a little pink/coral with my skin tone compared to what it looks like in the bottle but I don’t mind it!
This sheer wash of color paints on beautifully! It almost verges into coral territory, and really does look like the inside of a tomato. Such a pleasant and cheerful color that layers easily. It plays well with flaky toppers for jelly sandwich purposes, as seen here.
What a beautiful colour and formula, I can’t believe I ever hesitated to buy this polish. Tomato Tomahto is so cheerful and perfect for summer, I know it’ll be in heavy rotation for the whole season.
Absolutely love this formula and color! This one is on my thumb in the photo.
Super fun summer red. It skews slightly pink in 1-2 coats, but gets to perfect red in 3 coats (as shown)
Juicy red jelly! So pretty! Leans coral on me and reminds me of Cajun shrimp by opi, but this one is a much better formula! I love cracked jellies; they are so smooth and self leveling.
Squishy red :●)
I was really excited for this one. I have been searching for a bright red-orange. But mine is nothing like the product or review photos. Mine is more a pinkish-red. It seems like photos make it that bright red-orange color. I took a pic and it matches the photos but not in person. I added a little cornea killer on my ring finger to add some orange. I still like it, cracked jellies are the best!
I have pale skin with cool undertones and stick to blue-leaning reds. I wasn't sure if this would work on me because it looked slightly orange-leaning in the photos, but I couldn't resist -- it looked so juicy and beautiful. Turns out it's perfect! How?? I honestly don't know, it's surely some kind of magic. I'm convinced that whatever your undertones, this will work on you.
Stunning tomato jelly, was the perfect summer red for me!
I used three thin coats on top of a base coat. I should've used another coat of base coat because I had some nail staining on all of my nails. I also topped it with Broken Ornaments. All in all a beautiful manicure, but the brush itself was a little harder than the rest of the brushes I have and I am praying that my nail staining grows out ASAP.
I love this vibrant red polish. It dried pretty shiny without a top coat and it wore beautifully. It has become my go to red. It has a festive vibe and not at all moody.
It lasted so long and maintained the same jelly squish look!! Was looking for a high quality jelly red. This was it!!
You will absolutely love this polish if you get it!! It’s so simple yet so flattering. Smooth flawless application with a beautiful pop of color! Cracked has the best jellies around! (*gifted, but opinions are my own.)
I’ve been looking for a good solid read for a while. This one is like the ultimate summer fun bright red! Cracked’s jellies are my favorite, this one I built up in three coats. And I actually do say tomAHto lol
I love the tone and formula! It’s so smooth and dries perfectly. 2 coats worked for me.
The formula is a dream so no complaints there. On my skin tone it looks fluorescent coral, very odd and not at all what I was expecting, but that's a skin undertone thing. I worried it would be too orange for my liking, but turns out it isn't ENOUGH orange for my liking, when compared to an actual tomato. No fault of the polish, I knew going in that this probably wasn't going to work for me, I'm not a warm red, orange or coral polish wearer...just wish I was.
Cracked does such amazing jellies and I recently got into tending to a garden and when I saw this tomato red I knew I had to have it and I have not regreted for a moment. Whenever I run out I'll def be back for more!
I am in love with the jellies from Cracked and Tomato Tomahto is no exception. It's so juicy and smooth and builds up beautifully with each coat. In person, it looks a little less saturated and red; it feels more like a red-toned coral? But I'm not mad at it. I was looking for a fun, juicy warm-toned red for summer and this is it. Photo is 3 coats, pictured alongside 2 coats of Crimson Ecstasy.
