Skip to product information
1 of 23

Cream Of Mushroom

Cream Of Mushroom

Regular price $14.00
Regular price $0.00 Sale price $14.00
Sale Sold out
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Cream Of Mushroom is a dark tan with black flakes.

Opaque in 1-3 coats depending on nail length.

Texture Notice: This shade contains larger glitters and/or flakes that create a textured finish once dry. For a smoother finish, we recommend applying an extra layer of top coat.

Colors

  • Nude
  • Black

Finishes

  • Crelly
  • Flake

Ingredients

Butyl Acetate, Ethyl Acetate, Nitrocellulose, Adipic Acid/Neopentyl Glycol/Trimellitic Anhydride Copolymer, Acetyl Tributyl Citrate, Isopropyl Alcohol, Stearalkonium Bentonite, Acrylates Copolymer, Styrene/Acrylates Copolymer, Benzophenone-1, Silica, Trimethylpentanediyl Dibenzoate Ferric Ammonium Ferrocyanide, Mica , Titanium Dioxide, Tin Oxide, Black Iron Oxide, FD&C Yellow #5 Aluminum Lake

Size

15ml / 0.5oz

View full details

Acquired Tastes

Acquired Tastes Meet The Collection
  • 5 stars: 40 (100%)
  • 4 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 3 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 2 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 1 star: 0 (0%)
A
Anonymous
Something a little different

I was surprised by how much I love this weird color. And I got 10 days with no chips.

T
Tarie
My new favorite shade

I am falling in love with “cream of mushroom”. This shade is very unique.

h
handit.toomey
Unique Neutral

I love this polish, it makes for such a cool unique base for nail art, but also makes for such a pretty polish all on its own. Almost looks like handmade pottery.

C
Cierra R.
Obsessed

I’m so obsessed with this polish. I got about 10 polishes in my order, swatched them, and instantly had to do a full mani with this polish. It is so unique yet still simple and beautiful! A new favorite

A
Alyson
Murky and awesome

This unconventional prugly literally looks like cream of mushroom soup! It may lean greenish in some indoor lighting, but either way, it's murky and awesome. The formula is fantastic as always--very smooth and easy to apply. Love this polish so much!

J
J.
Most unique nail polish I own

I LOVE this color. It's so weird and unique but also adorable. I haven't been able to find anything like it and love that it's not for everybody. If you get it you get it. Excited to try it with a matte coat which I think will look great.

S
Sarah M.
So unique

Such a fun cutie weirdo shade. It reminds me of a fancy little egg shell. One coat was slightly sheer crelly, two was full coverage, nice smooth application and one coat of top coat was enough to smooth out the slight texture from the flakes.

K
Karina K.
Made me crave soup

Shade was so yummy-looking, it compelled me to make soup in the middle of the afternoon. One coat was prugly, two coats looked almost exactly like my soup! Formula was smooth and easy to apply as always!

B
Brooke
Monique is the Prugly Queen!

I was shocked at how much I actually loved this color! I thought it would be too yellow leaning of a beige color on my skintone. I would pick this one up!

K
Kristin H.
Unique Neutral

Not only is this polish one of the most unique in my collection, it's also gorgeous! If you're on the fence, give it a try and you might be pleasantly surprised! This is honestly one of my favorite purchases of the last year

A
Anonymous
Why do I kinda like it?

This is such a unique polish! I didn’t expect to like it so much, but after trying it on, it actually started to grow on me! Definitely for the prugly lovers!

A
AMANDA D.
Smooth and gross looking

Smooth and gross looking. Exactly what I wanted.

A
Anonymous
So unique!

Even for a prugly polish, this is a very unique polish! I love the black flakes and the tannish brown color!

P
Paula
Nice Prugly

Such a fun prugly. Looks perfect on the nail!

A
Anonymous
So unique!

I love this earthy beige base color! The black flakes makes for such a good combo with this color!

R
R.D.
Yummy!

Not quite tan, beige, or yellow, just something so prugly-y perfect. Scrumptious in a single coat, a really lovely, interesting, and perfectly weird gal. Get her!

A
A.
So fun!

In certain light, it reads a little greenish, and the black flakes come off more navy, which worked really well with my skin tone. I received far more compliments on this color than I would have expected!

T
Tricia J.
Looks just like the name

Love this so much. It truly looks like the inspiration and is dang prugly.

j
jr
Just like Campbell's used to make

Another great, unusual, realistic polish! Looks like it just plopped out of the can. With a matte coat it resembles a granite countertop. It just works.

L
Laura
Prugly Neutral

I really love this one. The addition of the black flakies is perfect. I'm definitely getting the sibling. Would love this in many different colors.

D
Deborah G.
Unique prugly

It’s just so weird you can’t help but love it

J
Jill

Quickly becoming my absolute favorite polish I’ve ever owned. This is beautiful on.

A
Andrea
Unique AND prugly! This polish really stands out

Unique AND prugly! This polish really stands out.

E
Eleanor D.
Soupy

I was initially on the fence about getting this. But I dig prugly colors & this one delivers. The name is perfect too. Reminds me of cream of mushroom soup. It’s a very unique color as well. Perfect in two coats.

I
Ida H.
Prugly 🤎

It was kinda an impulse buy, but I love it! Absolutely unique, unconditional beauty! Definitely not everyone's cup of tea, but if you like pruglies - you will love it! This one truly is special!

A
Anonymous
A neutral candy Robin's egg

I don't know what it is about this color but I'm obsessed.

K
Kassandra
Such a warm cozy but unique color

Such a warm cozy but unique color. Weird in a good way. I have deeper brown warm olive skin, and I personally liked this with my skintone, although its more of a personal preferance. Others with my silimar skin tone might not feel the same but I loved it! Got compliments too! My boyfriend is only really impressed by magnetic manis and certain creme polishes, lol, and even he was digging it.

r
rachel b.
yesss

so weird so prugly so wonderful, thanks for making the weird ones!

C
Cloudyday
Love this one, so unique and chic

Love this one, so unique and chic. The formula is great so creamy. I used it in 3 costs.

F
FREIDA R.
Prugly fun

This is unusual but fun